How to solve impunity when journalists are targeted

Those beyond the reach of attacking governments or groups must stand up for persecuted journalists and exert pressure.


Vanessa Berhe, centre, calls on the government to reveal the fate of dissidents who were detained 15 years ago and have been held incommunicado without trial [AFP]


Vanessa Berhe is the president of One Day Seyoum, a human rights group, and studies law at SOAS University of London.

I learned the true power of words when I was six years old. I had just started my first year of school in Sweden when my mother explained that my uncle was imprisoned in Eritrea, simply for speaking his mind.

The next day, I told my friends what I had learned and when our parents came to pick us up, they found us collecting money in plastic cups on the schoolyard. When one of the parents asked what we were doing, my friend explained my uncle's situation and said that we were telling people his story and collecting money to buy his release and a plane ticket.

My uncle's story had taught me that, if words alone were powerful enough to bring fear to the most powerful institution in a country, then they must be used actively, loudly, and fearlessly in order to bring about positive change in the world.

Any government which wants to unjustifiably and cruelly control their citizens is right to fear a free media.


Our right to express ourselves freely is quite understandably considered one of the most sacred principles of democracy.

When combined with an independent and responsible media platform, this freedom of expression is an essential part of a system of checks and balances that scrutinizes people in power and holds them accountable.

It informs the public, changes perceptions and initiates dialogues. It safeguards democracy and prevents tyranny. Any government which wants to unjustifiably and cruelly control their citizens is right to fear a free media.

The consequences of impunity are deadly. Not only are innocent people being killed for performing their civic duty and doing their job, but the stories that journalists are trying to tell are not being heard.

My uncle Seyoum Tsehaye was imprisoned is a journalist in 2001. Over 15 years later, he has still not been released. His imprisonment was a part of a wider campaign by the government to increase control in the country.

In the span of a week, the private media was shut down and all critical members of the government and outspoken journalists were imprisoned. I see the consequences of impunity in Eritrea every day, in the mass exodus from the country and the severe human rights violations they are fleeing.

Impunity is not restricted to Eritrea, which according to Reporters Without Borders is last on the global press freedom index, below China, Syria and North Korea.

Instead, it tends to exist in countries without democratic institutions to hold the government accountable for their unlawful actions.

Consequences of impunity

Governments all around the world silence people whose words they fear can challenge their power. Last year, UNESCO reported that on average, a journalist was killed every four days.

With critics out of the way, governments can use media platforms, with their carefully chosen words, as a means to control the people and set the narrative.

Just as easily as our words have the power to make positive change, they also have the power to corrupt.


The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) wrote in a 2014 report: "Targeted attacks on the media have kept the world from understanding the full dimension of the violence taking place in Syria. Unchecked impunity has suppressed critical reporting on drug trafficking in Mexico, militant violence in Pakistan, and corruption in Russia."

The targeted attacks and unchecked impunity play a key role to why all of the problems mentioned above still persist, three years after the report was written. The consequences of impunity are, indeed, dangerous and deadly.

But to argue that freedom of expression only is being under attack in authoritarian states would be a misstatement.

Media cannot simply exist on its own, it also needs to be independent and responsible. If not, it can easily be used as a tool to deceive, manipulate and control, and affect innocent people's lives.

The 'lying' American president

Our current political climate has shown just how vulnerable media is to becoming corrupt, regardless of where in the world it is.

In the United States, a country that prides itself in their democracy, the current president has declared a war on media. But it is not a war on the entire media, only the ones he does not agree with. The ones he does agree with, he uses as sources for his speeches, sometimes without checking the accuracy.

Seyoum Tsehaye was imprisoned in 2001 [Vanessa Berhe/Al Jazeera]

Like most Swedes, I was confused when the current US president implied that there had been some kind of terrorist attack by refugees in Sweden the night before.

My social media feeds instantly filled up with sources refuting such an attack and it was quickly confirmed that no attack of any kind had happened in Sweden. The president had based his statement on a segment he had seen on Fox News, a right-wing news channel often criticized for its bias.

The danger here is not only that the US has a president who actively and unapologetically lies about marginalized groups and pressing issues, but that there is a large group of people whose perception of reality is largely based on speeches from their leader and segments of biased and irresponsible news channels.

As far as they were concerned, a terrorist attack had been committed by refugees and anything stating the contrary could easily be brushed off as "fake news", just as the current US president labels news reports he simply does not agree with.

A former US ambassador to the United Nations once said: "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts."

Today, those words are more important than ever. The media decides which stories they tell and how they do so.

When they attack, we need to shout even louder ... with our words alone we can do wonders. Let us not let that power go to waste.


Demonizing a group of people while camouflaging bigotry as fact can have dangerous implications - we do not need to look far back in history to find proof of that.

How do we then ensure that the validity of truth is not jeopardized, impunity is ended and freedom of expression can flourish?

We can only do that by protecting this democratic principle - actively, loudly, and fearlessly.

OPINION: The media should resist far-right populist tendencies

We need to constantly stay critical and challenge the narrative we have been presented, regardless of whether it's propaganda from a dictatorship, a news report from a supposedly independent source, or a speech from a democratically elected president. The failure to do so will undoubtedly lead to terrible injustice.

We need to hold governments who silence journalists and citizens accountable and speak up for those who cannot themselves. Governments might be able to silence their own citizens, but they cannot possibly silence the outside world.

It is only when impunity itself is challenged by those beyond the reach of the attacking government that it can be ended.

Foreign governments, international institutions, corporations, activists, journalists and world citizens all play a role in holding abusive governments accountable. Even the most isolated dictatorships are not immune from external pressure.

Seyoum Tsehaye's family lives in Sweden [Vanessa Berhe/Al Jazeera]

We need to be persistent.

A very long time has passed since I found out my uncle was imprisoned and I am still campaigning for his release. They wanted to silence him, so I decided to become his voice. They wanted him to be forgotten, so I decided to tell the whole world his story.

Challenging governments is not easy and it will take time.

When they try to block us, we need to find new routes. When they attack, we need to shout even louder. My then six-year-old friends understood it quickly; with our words alone we can do wonders. Let us not allow that power go to waste.

Vanessa Berhe is the president of One Day Seyoum, a human rights organisation working for the release of unjustly imprisoned people in Eritrea. She is studying law at SOAS University of London.

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

Source: Al Jazeera

Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.

Take Action

Eritrean Satellite Television is an international non-profit organization. Please support us by:


Sign up


Spread the word

Top Leaders

Top 50 Most Earned Points (All time)

Yosief Meharena 1
+5371pt earned points
Zaid Bein 2
+5275pt earned points
efrem tesfay 3
+5024pt earned points
Andebrhan Ekube 4
+4527pt earned points
Hamer Diglel 5
+3255pt earned points
Yosief Meharena 6
+3034pt earned points
Efrem Tesfahiwet 7
+2960pt earned points
Solomon Ghebrewold 8
+1270pt earned points
Yemane Ghebrekidan 9
+974pt earned points
Khalieb Abraham 10
+725pt earned points
Kidane Weldemichael 11
+585pt earned points
Anonymous 12
+515pt earned points
Tewelde Kidane 13
+480pt earned points
Abeba Abraha 14
+430pt earned points
Amanuel Mebrahtu 15
+402pt earned points
stifanos michael 16
+392pt earned points
Haile Tensae 17
+313pt earned points
Yohannes T. Berhe 18
+295pt earned points
Teclemariam Ghebregergis 19
+295pt earned points
Abdu Ali 20
+280pt earned points
Robi91 Smerr1 21
+275pt earned points
rezene yowhans 22
+262pt earned points
smuy 23
+255pt earned points
Zery Bokre 24
+245pt earned points
Mesfin Kidane 25
+240pt earned points
Asefaw Ghebrekidan 26
+235pt earned points
Biniam Biniam Garmskal 27
+233pt earned points
Kassahun Berhane 28
+230pt earned points
Shaban Mohammed 29
+210pt earned points
Tesheme Temesgen 30
+200pt earned points
Negede Tesfamariam 31
+188pt earned points
Ugbaldet G. Kidane 32
+176pt earned points
amanuel mebrahtu 33
+171pt earned points
abdu Ahmed 34
+170pt earned points
yacob sibhat 35
+170pt earned points
asgedet tesfa yohannes 36
+165pt earned points
tekle teklzghi 37
+155pt earned points
Ardel_Gash Y. Negash 38
+152pt earned points
Ali Baba Ali Baba 39
+145pt earned points
okubay hagos 40
+135pt earned points
selam fithat selam fithat 41
+130pt earned points
Haile Woldemichael 42
+130pt earned points
Saba Keleta 43
+125pt earned points
yehdego beyene 44
+125pt earned points
Habte Berhe 45
+125pt earned points
Eyassu Tesfamariam 46
+125pt earned points
Asmerom Asfaha 47
+120pt earned points
Gebrihiwet Gebremedhin 48
+120pt earned points
Tesfay Beraki 49
+120pt earned points
Yohanns Ghebrezghi 50
+115pt earned points

Upcoming Events