UN criticises tightened Swiss policy on Eritreans

One of the United Nations’ top human rights experts says Switzerland had no good reason to crack down on Eritreans.

François Crépeau, a Canadian lawyer who serves as the UN’s special rapporteur on the human rights of migrants, lashed out at Switzerland’s recent decision to tighten its asylum policy towards Eritreans in an interview with two Swiss newspapers on Friday.

On February 2, the Federal Administrative Court said Switzerland would no longer recognise Eritreans as refugees solely on grounds of having fled their country illegally. Until last summer, leaving Eritrea illegally was considered a legitimate reason for asylum, since whoever did so faced up to five years in prison in Eritrea.

 

However, the court decided “the illegal exit [from Eritrea] cannot in itself justify recognition as a refugee”, pointing to recent cases of Eritreans returning safely for short home visits after gaining asylum status in Switzerland.

Crépeau, whose job involves investigating human rights violations and promoting sound policies globally, said in an interview with the Tages-Anzeiger and Berner Zeitung there was no evidence that someone returning to Eritrea would not face punishment.

“Switzerland must be certain, in every single case, that a return for an individual will not be problematic. This requires a mechanism that can check that after returning nothing indeed happens,” he said.

Crépeau said Switzerland was “pretty much on its own” on this issue and warned against tightening policy based on doubts. Instead, he concluded, the rule should be: if in doubt, err on the side of protection.

The Swiss government’s policy for processing asylum requests from Eritrean refugees is important because Eritreans make up the largest single nationality among asylum seekers in Switzerland: some 5,000 a year.


Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.

Take Action

Eritrean Satellite Television is an international non-profit organization. Please support us by:

Donate

Sign up

Volunteer

Spread the word

Top Leaders

Top 50 Most Earned Points (All time)

1
+6196pt earned points
2
+5185pt earned points
3
+5024pt earned points
4
+4567pt earned points
5
+3295pt earned points
6
+2960pt earned points
7
+1514pt earned points
8
+1495pt earned points
9
+720pt earned points
10
+702pt earned points
11
+515pt earned points
12
+495pt earned points
13
+480pt earned points
14
+466pt earned points
15
+402pt earned points
16
+395pt earned points
17
+377pt earned points
18
+333pt earned points
19
+285pt earned points
20
+280pt earned points
21
+275pt earned points
22
+264pt earned points
23
+245pt earned points
24
+233pt earned points
25
+230pt earned points
26
+215pt earned points
27
+210pt earned points
28
+200pt earned points
29
+188pt earned points
30
+185pt earned points
31
+171pt earned points
32
+170pt earned points
33
+170pt earned points
34
+155pt earned points
35
+152pt earned points
36
+145pt earned points
37
+145pt earned points
38
+135pt earned points
39
+130pt earned points
40
+125pt earned points
41
+125pt earned points
42
+120pt earned points
43
+120pt earned points
44
+120pt earned points
45
+112pt earned points
46
+112pt earned points
47
+110pt earned points
48
+110pt earned points
49
+110pt earned points
50
+110pt earned points

Upcoming Events